The Best Dark Rum in 2025: Our Ultimate Selection

The Best Dark Rum in 2025: Our Ultimate Selection

Dark Rum: the darker cousin of gold rum and a classic for strong cocktails created for slow, intentional sipping. This rum, made from caramelized molasses, ages for much longer in heavily charred barrels.

You'll know this drink instantly by its black or red hues. Occasionally, you'll come across rum with caramel added for a rich, deep brown color. The flavor is just as bold, with notes of spice and smoke. You can have it neat or mix it in a Dark ‘n’ Stormy for that extra kick. 

If that sounds good, this guide is for you. We'll cover our top Dark Rum picks and explore how to choose the best Dark Rum, whether it's for cocktails or drinking straight.  And if you're curious about other rum options, our best rum guide has you covered.

Read More
best of other spirits
$50 & Under
$100 & Under
$250 & Under
Splurge Worthy Gifts

Our Top 5 Best Dark Rum Picks Best Dark Rum Choices

Here are the details of our five favorite Dark Rum options that our team chose based on flavor profiles, presentation, and experience.

Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Don Papa Small Batch Rum

1.

Don Papa Small Batch Rum

Don Papa
· 750ml · 40% ABV
About Don Papa Small Batch Rum

The First Sipping Rum from the Philippines.   Don Papa was started in 2011 by Stephen Carroll, a former exec at Remy Cointreau. Inspiration came during a visit of Philippines’ sugar capital of Negros. Carroll was fascinated by the stories of an island that had everything; from the World’s finest...

View more about Don Papa Small Batch Rum >>
Regular
$49.99
Flaviar black
$44.99 (−10%)
Don Papa Small Batch Rum Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color
Light amber

Smell / Nose / Aroma
Light and fruity

Flavor / Taste / Palate
Smooth and delicate. Vanilla, oak, honey with notes of candied fruits throughout.

Finish
Rich

Brugal 1888 Double Aged Rum
Brugal 1888 Double Aged Rum

2.

Brugal 1888 Double Aged Rum

Brugal
About Brugal 1888 Double Aged Rum

The Rum for Whisky lovers. Introducing Brugal 1888, an innovative twist on traditional rum that speaks to the refined palate of whisky aficionados. Born from the visionary spirit of Don Andres Brugal Montaner in 1888, this rum was crafted to defy conventions and offer something distinctly different. So, what sets...

View more about Brugal 1888 Double Aged Rum >>
$44.99
Brugal 1888 Double Aged Rum Tasting Notes
Appearance / Color

Amber

Nose / Aroma / Smell

Inviting with red fruits, vanilla, spices, chocolate, roasted coffee, and cinnamon.

Flavor / Taste / Palate

Smooth & full bodied with flavors of toffee, vanilla, cocoa, natural oak spice, caramel, wood and liquorice.

Finish

Long-lasting

Plantation Barbados XO 20th Anniversary Rum
Plantation Barbados XO 20th Anniversary Rum

3.

Plantation Barbados XO 20th Anniversary Rum

Plantation Rum
· 750ml · 40% ABV
About Plantation Barbados XO 20th Anniversary Rum

Rum category Winner of the Flaviar Community Awards 2018. Plantation Rum is owned by French Cognac producer Maison Ferrand, who control no less than a dozen major brands premium Spirits and liqueurs. Sometimes that is an iffy proposition, but not in this case because the folks at Ferrand are...

View more about Plantation Barbados XO 20th Anniversary Rum >>
Regular
$60.99
Flaviar black
$57.94 (−5%)
Plantation Barbados XO 20th Anniversary Rum Tasting Notes
Appearance / Color
Warm cherry-wood
 
Nose / Aroma / Smell
Oak, caramel, toasted coconut and sweet vanilla. 
 
Flavor / Taste / Palate
Natural heat, caramelized honey, milk chocolate with orange zest throughout.
 
Finish 
Long, warm and cinnamon orange sticks. 
Appleton Estate 8 Year Old Reserve
Appleton Estate 8 Year Old Reserve

4.

Appleton Estate 8 Year Old Reserve

Appleton Estate
About Appleton Estate 8 Year Old Reserve

250 years of mastery in one single bottle. Appleton-branded liquid gold has been in constant production here since 1749. Appleton Estate sits in the Nassau Valley of Jamaica — an amazing rain forest with steeply domed hills and narrow valleys filled with some of the finest "terra rosa" soils on...

View more about Appleton Estate 8 Year Old Reserve >>
Regular
$47.99
Flaviar black
$38.39 (−20%)
Appleton Estate 8 Year Old Reserve Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color
Honeyed bronze

Nose / Aroma / Smell
Spicy fruit aromas and hints of honey.

Flavor / Taste / Palate
Smooth with vanilla, holiday spice, and orange peel flavors.

Finish
Smooth

Brugal Añejo Rum
Brugal Añejo Rum

5.

Brugal Añejo Rum

Brugal
· 750ml · 40% ABV
About Brugal Añejo Rum

This is arguably Brugal’s most popular Rum — with good reason.   Don Andrés Brugal Montaner founded Brugal & Co, in 1888 in the Dominican Republic near Puerto Plata — Silver Port — on the north side of the island. Five generations of the family have worked the stills and...

View more about Brugal Añejo Rum >>
$22.99
Brugal Añejo Rum Tasting Notes
Appearance / Color
Medium Amber
 
Nose / Aroma / Smell
On the nose you’ll find toasted wood, toffee, vanilla, black pepper, and a hint of watermint. 
 
Flavor / Taste / Palate
The palate is rich and dry with brown butter sauce, oak, and molasses.
 
Finish 
The finish is loner with turbinado sugar and spices.

How to Choose the Best Dark Rum?

Buying Dark Rum can often be a bit of a gamble. It’s easy to stick to big names like Plantation Rum, but a little bit of experimentation with lesser-known brands keeps things fresh. That said, there are two main things to consider: the production method and the aging process. 

The production method shapes the overall character of Dark Rum, while aging adds the richness and complexity that make it memorable. It's also worth paying attention to where the rum originates, since regional styles can vary significantly.

Best Dark Rum for Cocktails

The best Dark Rums for cocktails like the Dark ‘n’ Stormy or the Detroit Daisy are the ones with a bold flavor that aren’t excessively aged or obscenely expensive. These rums have a rich molasses base, but their depth is not overpowering and is just enough to make them stand out when mixed with other ingredients.

Best Dark Rum for Drinking Straight 

Did you know that Dark Rums were originally enjoyed straight or on the rocks? The rich flavors developed through years of barrel aging are best experienced without mixers. We recommend choosing rum aged at least five to seven years. Premium labels like “aged,” “reserve,” or “single barrel” usually indicate quality.

How Much Does Dark Rum Cost?

Dark rum usually falls between $30 and $65. Aged and premium bottles cost more, so think about what you want to use it for before you buy dark rum. If you’re in the mood to splurge, however, feel free to explore our list of the best rums under $200 for something extra special.

More Top Dark Rum Options