The only Bourbon to ever win the double gold medal five times.
The Eagle Rare Bourbon was created by Seagram master distiller Charles L. Beam and introduced in 1975. It stands as one of the last new Bourbon brands introduced before the current era of small batch Bourbons. In the years since it was acquired by numerous companies before it became a part of the Buffalo Trace distillery.
Eagle Rare 10YO Bourbon was aged for 10 years in new oak casks. It has claimed over 30 awards in the past decade, including 5 Double Gold medals at the SFWSC. In terms of price/quality ratio, you would be hard pressed to find a better value Bourbon as this one. Bourbon bang-for-the-buck of the year. And pretty quite damn spectacular as well.
Kind of a cinnamon spiciness but not too overwhelming and still definitely has that caramel/vanilla sweetness. I could see this being good in fall and Christmas themed drinks.
Smooth drinker. Butterscotch and caramel hits thick and smooth. Excellent finish.
Easy to drink. Goes down great straight.
My daily driver
Buffalo Trace and this are very close in terms of my favorite bourbons. I’d give the slight edge to Buffalo Trace but this is soooo close. The nose is pleasant with apples and pear and the slightest bit of spice. The taste is great with vanilla and sweetness similar to fruit but not too fruity where it’s overwhelming. Amazing bourbon and worth a try.
It’s good! You get the sweet notes with a smack of spice. It’s dryer than my other favorites , have a dram !
The Buffalo Trace mash bill with a bit more aging and tender care. It drinks more smoothly than BT, and I have found it to be a wonderful bottle to gift because it's accessible by new drinkers, presents well, and is relatively, well, rare.
Very smooth. One of my favorites
exceptionally smooth, great flavor, easy to drink.
Pretty darn good
Simple, classic bourbon. Best value for the price! Easy decision!
This is a great price for a great tasting whiskey.
Wonderfully smooth throughout
Eagle Rare is always terrific. Please do not send any more tasting boxes for scotch or straight rye boubon
What a beautiful creation. The nose is rich with spice, caramel, vanilla and cherries. Through the first sip, a slightly smoky and dry oak shine through with hints of butterscotch and fruits. Each subsequent taste brings more cinnamon, nutmeg, apricot and plums into a wonderful complexly medium finish urging for another drink. One of the best bourbons for your buck, period.
I was very impressed with this bourbon. Great nose, sweet, great finish. For the price, much better value than more expensive bourbons. Just became one of my favorites. (Along with Joseph Magnus and Blanton's)
Sweet, very good , very similar to buffalo trace
Nose is very similar to Buffalo Trace, sweet, with just a mild hint of toffee. First sip is surprisingly mellow, just a little sweet, with an oilier mouthfeel than Buffalo Trace, pleasantly different. Subtle notes of cinnamon and nutmeg start to show, before a lingering dry baking spice finish. With a few drops of water, this really shines. I started picking up apple on the nose, and the flavor on the front of the palate along with a little vanilla. The baking spices, particularly the cinnamon, still shine through a nice finish.
Tasted alongside Woodford and Evan Williams White Label, and this just didn't hold up to either. Some light cinnamon notes, but the flavor is a bit flat.
My favorite (so far)
Great for mixing and slow sipping with ice. Vanilla with low alcohol burn
Sweet and leather
Yum. Buffalo Trace was lost on me until I had Eagle Rare. A hearty grainier bourbon, Eagle Rare has a robust flavor complexity that is easy to drink and fun to drink explore.
Favorite so far, slightly sweet, complex, without any one flavor overpowering.
My favorite Bourbon. Has one of the best Buffalo Trace mashbills, and just enough oak/wood taste and burn... Really good and lasting finish, as well.
Excellent bourbon for the price. Taste like a more expensive bottle. Very smooth. Not much burn. Clean finish.
As a burgeoning bourbon aficionado, my collection is still rather small. As such, the Eagle Rare 10 Year is the first bourbon with an age statement that I have purchased, and despite the fact that the high speed bottling line used by Buffalo Trace prevents them from any longer using the "single barrel" descriptor, this is technically my first single barrel as well. With those attributes in mind, along with the bottle's stellar reviews and recommendations, I was very eager to try this one. At $35, my wallet was eager to let me.
The nose is citrusy sweet with orange and honey dominating and the smell of the charred oak tagging onto the end. The palate is oily enough to coat the mouth without being too thick and the taste is sweet. The citrus continues and is aided by dark cherries and brown sugar caramel. As it hits the back of the tongue, the flavor brings the spice of cinnamon and pepper with the charred oak becoming more prominent. The finish is moderately long and pleasant with lingering honey, vanilla, and faint chocolate. I almost hesitate to add yet another positve review to the growing library of Eagle Rare commentary lest the fine folks at Buffalo Trace finally wise up and charge what this bottle is worth. In the mean time, grab a bottle, pour it neat or on the rocks, and find somewhere quiet to sip it and watch the sun set.
Late night, sitting on front porch relaxing sipper to quiet the senses
Amazing budget bourbon. Costs $35 (in Oregon), drinks like a $50+ bottle.
One of my favorites. An easy sipper. Smooth, clean finish.
A little sharp and oily. Tastes like it needs more time in the barrel, a very sharp flavor and nose.
Great for relaxing on the deck and letting the sun set. Very smooth and great taste.
Smooth, great bourbon
Great everyday drinking bottle. Smooth and easy to drink. Great bourbon for the price!
This is one of my top 4 favorites without getting into the expensive types. I have no problem serving it to guests.
Good everyday drinker.
My favorite so far!
For an ultra-low rye, it's amazing. I like mine on ice and without ice I like it with a good medium rare steak. Was one of the first Bourbons I've tried and have not regretted it.
The next logical step up from Buffalo Trace is this (as some would say) 10yr version. A must have staple for anyone lucky enough to grab one for under $40. Aromatics: nicely aged Oak, caramel and a Madagascar vanilla spice that just fills the air with a faint scent of something floral. Taste: a bit of rye spice with lingering butterscotch and Cracker Jack popcorn and peanuts. There is an orange citrus sweet and sour finish that simmers in the spice and lingers on for a bit. I will be getting more to replace what I just opened.
One of my favorites. Great neat or on the rocks and makes a killer mint julep if you're in the mood for a summer cocktail!
Phenomenal and underrated.
My go to Bourbon! Love this stuff, especially for the price point
Love this bourbon. Great with a nice cigar
Love it. It's is one of the best bourbon whiskeys I have tried especially for the price point. In my state
Fantastic sipping whisky, no guilt. Good for mixing. Strong burn on finish. Sweet notes of caramel, toffee.
Smooth and easy to go on the rocks.
Strong alcohol fire on the palate, cools down with a sweet kick
Alex is spot on - good go to bourbon. Consistent. Good enough to serve to friends, and satisfying alone. Complex enough to keep me interested each sip.
With hints of burnt caramel and sugar, this $35 bottle of bourbon is delicious. I also picked up on more floral and perfume like flavors that kind if remind me ever so slightly of Jack Daniels. It had a nice, smooth, and spicy finish that really brings it all together for this bottle. I'd say it's value really makes it great. This will be another staple bottle on my shelf.
My go to budget Bourbon. Got a little barrel punch which I like. Perfect for when I just want a good bourbon and dont want to think about it.
Smooth. Good by the dram or in a mixed drink.
This is a very drinkable bourbon for the price. I have sampled it both neat and in a mint julep and it worked well in both. This is one of the most enjoyable bourbons I have drank, better than some of the higher end ones I have tried.
If you like Buffalo Trace bourbon, this is the older brother. Good complexity and linger.
Real real good....definitely gonna have to grab a couple more bottles of this! Just a solid full and rich flavor.
Doesn’t have the sweet flavor I associate with (and don’t like) about bourbon. Smooth and delicious
Smooth and pretty tasty. Easy to like.
Smooth and oh so sweet
Sweet up front with a spicy finish. Can’t beat it for $40 or less.
It is just a really good bourbon, price aside. Love it if you haven't yet buy a bottle its value is hard to beat.
What else can you get with this quality and depth of flavor for sub-40 dollars? Hint: You can't. Sweet easy drinking bourbon.
This is a really good combine of a great bourbon at a low price point. Keep a bottle or two around before it gets scarce.
Very Good Bourbon. Great just by it's self or made into a whiskey sour.
Favorite daily drinker
Very smooth. Well worth the price.
Smooth as silk and highly drinkable, the flavor and quality for this price point have very little competition!
It is very very good
Good, smooth, daily drinker. Not very complex
Very good, simple and for the price one of the best bourbons I have had, this is a great go to for me, I wish they would sell it in SW Florida
First scent was of cherries and licorice. Spicy caramel notes at first. Finishes with honey vanilla and sweetness.
Everything they make is world class and each a little different. the key word here is Rare, I think its going to be harder and harder to capture this smoothy.
Easy to drink but the mouth feel is very watery.
My go to! Great neat, or in your favorite mixture. Smooth from the beginning. Traces of caramel and vanilla linger through a long, spicey finish. You will be hard pressed to find a better bourbon for the price!
Slightly sweeter than Buffalo Trace but one of the best bottles you can get for around $33
Smooth with a low heat, layered honey and vanilla sweetness. So good.
A sharp entry that softens quickly, take some time under the tongue and you'll be well rewarded...
I like this one a lot. It is enjoyable on its own and mixes well. I will be buying this one again
For the money its s great drink!!
For the price point, this lives up to the hype. Soft, subtle nose of oak, toffee, vanilla and toasted coconut. The front of the palate is surprisingly spicy, giving way to oak tannins, vanilla, more toasted coconut and a hint of mint on the finish. Nice after dinner sipper.
Absolutely the finest bourbon for the price. Delightful sipper, nice and sweet and smooth, and it mixes very well.
Easy Drinkin' intro bourbon. Great for cocktails!
Excellent value. Very easy drinker with a nice vanilla lead and oaky bite at the end!
It was pretty good. Not great but foot. Price wasnt bad ($42)
A great sipping whiskey, easy to drink, starts with some caramel, followed by some more complex flavors, carries a nice burn down and has a clean finish.
My favorite sipping whiskey. Lots of flavor with little bite
SMOOTH. Just enough spice. Very nice finish
Most excellent for the price
Good flavor, relatively short finish, not incredibly complex, has a little more burn than it should for this profile and price.
A bit spicy for my taste, even with a little water. Now I just mix it.
One of my go to for entertaining especially new ones to bourbon. Makes a great gift.
Very smooth with a light kick on the back end. Great stuff for the price, highly recommend a try.
Great sipping bourbon
Smooth slightly sweet, light spice note good Carmel and wood notes medium finish
Used to like this a lot more when it was single barrel but they have since moved to blended making it all fairly uniform instead of never knowing exactly how the next bottle was going to taste. A bit rougher on the palate but an easy enough finish.
my favorite bourbon - sweet on the nose, incredibly flavorful palate with caramel and vanilla, and a great smooth finish. this is my go to and the whisky i show to people who are looking to get into whisky.
Very smooth, no hard bite after taste. I would buy this again!
Superb bourbon. Well balanced, smooth.
Nose: oak, honey, clove
Taste: oak, cinnamon, clove, vanilla, red apple, medium finish with leather
Sweet and smooth. Kind of too smooth and missing other flavors.
Best bourbon there is. Especially for what it costs. Eagle Rare can easily stand up to the big $150 bourbons.
This is my go to bourbon, especially if I am offering to folks who may not go for whiskey. So smooth, and with an interesting blend of sweet vanilla notes and oak-y flavor that I always poor a little more than I should when I pull this bottle off the shelf.
Consumed neat. Just a damn good bourbon.
I found the candy notes to be not as satisfying of a bourbon sweetness, but this was a fairly popular one with my friends in a blind tasting. Overall solid dram.
Favorite Mid-tier Bourbon. This will be served at our wedding.
Very nice, especially for the price!
This is the smoothest bourbon I have run across to date. Great straight or mixed in your favorite cocktail. If it was any smoother, it would probably be illegal. Not too sweet and not bitter. It has just enough bite to leave no doubt about the fact that it’s the real deal. If you like bourbon, you’ll love Eagle Rare.
Like it . Its It's a very solid safe go to if you're bringing it to the party to share.
Smooth like butter. This one is good anyway you like to drink your whiskey.
Good every day bourbon
So smooth, the best I have had.
One of my favorites, and at a great price!
Top notch. Affordable and provides great flavor and smooth sipping quality. Love this.
Amazing deal for the price.
One of my favorite's along with Buffalo Trace!
Very smooth with caramel notes.
Will always keep this one stocked in my private reserve.
Buffalo Trace (those crafty mad-men in Kentucky) took bourbon, and aged like scotch. The result is a more refined flavor, and texture that only ten years can provide. Oaky, sweet, smells of vanilla; a fine spirit for the fine lady and gentleman.
It has enough strength to push you over, yet has enough restraint to allow you to enjoy it. It's not easy to find. And when it IS on the shelf, its gone quickly. $30-$40 is the average price for a bottle, and it is money very well spent.
A wonderful bourbon that's surprisingly cheap for how smooth it is. There are a lot of sweet and spicy notes that are well balanced.
Great for its price point
It definitely falls in line with the other Buffalo Trace bourbons with slightly more refinement than the basic Buffalo Trace bottles, but not as much complexity as the Blanton's Original. The profile is less on the sweet spectrum and more on the spicy side to me, but just as smooth as what you'd expect.
It definitely falls in line with the other Buffalo Trace bourbons with slightly more refinement than the basic Buffalo Trace bottles, but not as much complexity as the Blanton's Original. The profile is less sweet to me, but just as smooth.
This is my favorite all around bourbon. This is sipping stuff at its greatest. Lucky to have found it in my area as the distributors are stingy with it.
A really solid whiskey for such a modest price point