The Best Whiskey for a Manhattan in 2025: Our Favorite Picks

The Best Whiskey for a Manhattan in 2025: Our Favorite Picks

Manhattans are classic cocktails made with whiskey, sweet vermouth, and bitters. While not the trendiest drink right now, they remain the go-to choice for anyone who loves bold, spirited flavors with just the right hint of sweetness and complexity. 

The taste changes depending on the whiskey you pick, but expect notes of peppery spice, vanilla, caramel, and oak.

If you want to craft the perfect drink, you need the best whiskey for a Manhattan in your glass. We look at some of the best whiskey in this guide, all of which are available on Flaviar. Get ready to take your cocktail game to the next level. Keep reading to find your next favorite bottle!

Read More
BEST OF OTHER SPIRITS
Best Bourbon Under $100
Best Scotch Under $100
Best Irish Whiskey Under $100
Best Cognac Under $100

Our Top 5 Best Whiskeys for a Manhattan Best Whiskey for a Manhattan Selections

These are our top picks for the best whiskey for a Manhattan based on their flavor, finish, and ability to balance with the sweetness and bitters.

BHAKTA 1928 Rye Whiskey
BHAKTA 1928 Rye Whiskey

1.

BHAKTA 1928 Rye Whiskey

Bhakta Spirits
About BHAKTA 1928 Rye Whiskey

This Rye Whiskey isn’t just any bottle—it’s leveled up with Armagnac, and we’re talking vintage Armagnac from 1928! Yep, this blend includes Armagnac from 1928, 1941, 1962, 1973, and even 1996, giving you a taste of nearly the entire 20th century in one pour. 

On top of that, the blend averages 15 years of age, making it an absolute steal for the price. It’s history, flavor, and value all wrapped into one incredible whiskey, making it the best Rye Whiskey you can get your hands on.

View more about BHAKTA 1928 Rye Whiskey >>
$88.99
BHAKTA 1928 Rye Whiskey Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color

Golden orange color in an elegant glass bottle.

Nose / Aroma

Caramel, vanilla, and custard aroma.

Flavor / Taste / Palate

Powerful vanilla, oak, and spice flavors.

Finish

A lingering finish of oak and tannins that's mellow enough to keep you coming back for more.

Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

2.

Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

Longbranch
· 750ml · 43% ABV
About Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey

In 2016, Wild Turkey Master Distiller Eddie Russell teamed up with Matthew McConaughey to create a bourbon celebrating their shared love of whiskey. The Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey blends smoky Texan mesquite with classic Kentucky craftsmanship, delivering sweet, bold, and balanced flavors. 

Its flavor profile makes it a fantastic choice for Manhattans, adding depth and a subtle smokiness that takes the cocktail to the next level while staying easy to enjoy on its own.

View more about Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey >>
Regular
$41.99
Flaviar black
$35.69 (−15%)
Longbranch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color

Deep amber.

Nose / Aroma

Sweet scents of caramel and butterscotch, with subtle citrus zest.

Flavor / Taste / Palate

Notes of vanilla, dark caramel, and pear, along with spicy undertones of cinnamon and toasted oak.

Finish

Long and smoky.

Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey
Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey

3.

Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey

Sazerac Rye
· 750ml · 45% ABV
About Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey

Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey is a true classic. Born at the legendary Buffalo Trace Distillery, it’s the perfect rye for anyone who loves history and a killer cocktail. While it originally replaced Cognac in the classic Sazerac cocktail, this whiskey stands strong on its own. 

With a crisp, clean taste and a bold character, it’s earned rave reviews–including a 94.5 rating from Jim Murray and gold medals in LA and San Francisco. This is a top-tier rye whiskey you won’t want to miss.

View more about Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey >>
$24.99
Sazerac Straight Rye Whiskey Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color

Deep amber with rich, warm tones.

Nose / Aroma

A burst of rye spice, complemented by notes of vanilla, oak, and a hint of sweetness.

Flavor / Taste / Palate

Smooth and balanced, with caramel, vanilla, and a peppery spice that adds depth.

Finish

A long finish with notes of honey and a subtle, spicy warmth.

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon
Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon

4.

Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon

Elijah Craig
About Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon

Elijah Craig’s Small Batch Bourbon is a prime example of the best small batch bourbon. Coming from one of the oldest distilleries in the U.S., Heaven Hill in Kentucky, this bourbon is well-known for its rich smokey oak flavor, which is the result of the unique small-batch process. It has a mellow, full-bodied taste that’s balanced with notes of vanilla, caramel, and spice.

It’s easy to find at most liquor stores and online, made with a mash bill of 78% corn, 10% rye, and 12% malted barley.

View more about Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon >>
Regular
$29.99
Flaviar black
$26.99 (−10%)
Elijah Craig Small Batch Bourbon Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color

Burnished copper.

Nose / Aroma

Vanilla and mint with a hint of sweet fruits.

Flavor / Taste / Palate

Warming spices, distinctive charred smokey notes, hints of nutmeg and honey.

Finish

Long, slightly toasty and warm finish.

Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey
Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey

5.

Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey

Jaywalk
About Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey

The fading New York rye style comes alive again with Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey. Finished right in the heart of New York, it offers a bold and unique flavor experience. Each sip takes you on a journey, from tropical fruit bursts to delicate floral notes that linger on the palate. 

Its complexity transforms a Manhattan into a vibrant, unforgettable cocktail that every whiskey lover should experience.

View more about Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey >>
$48.99
Jaywalk Straight Rye Whiskey Tasting Notes

Appearance / Color

Gold and amber.

Nose / Aroma

Apricots and pineapple, with floral notes and caramelized sugars. 

Flavor / Taste / Palate

Tropical fruity notes with rye and caramel.

Finish

Sweet and long lasting.

What Is a Good Whiskey Manhattan Recipe?

Try this recipe for a whiskey Manhattan that’s bold, sophisticated, and guaranteed to impress:

  • 2 ounces of bourbon or Rye Whiskey
  • 1 ounce of sweet vermouth
  • 2 dashes of bitters in a mixing glass with ice

Give those ingredients a good, vigorous stir until the mixture is perfectly chilled. Then strain it into a sleek, frosty coupe or martini glass. Finish it off with a brandied cherry or a zesty orange twist to add a splash of flair and a burst of aroma.

How to Choose the Best Whiskey for a Manhattan?

The sort of whiskey that goes well in a Manhattan depends on what you’re going for. If you want a spicy, dry edge, try traditional Rye Whiskey. If you’re craving something smoother and sweeter, bourbon is the way to go. Look for notes of spice, caramel, and oak that aren’t too subtle. 

How Much Does a Whiskey for a Manhattan Cost?

You don’t have to break the bank to buy whiskey that suits a Manhattan. With $25 to $60, you can score fantastic bottles like Rittenhouse Rye, Bulleit Bourbon, or Wild Turkey 101, all of which are solid choices that bring bold flavor without emptying your wallet. If you want more options, we recommend taking a look at our list of best whiskey under $100.

Can You Drink the Same Whiskey Straight You Used in a Manhattan?

Most whiskeys you use in a Manhattan work just as well straight. Whiskeys with rich, layered flavors offer a satisfying sip neat or on the rocks, though some may not mix as well in cocktails.

What Other Cocktails Can You Make With Whiskey?

Whiskey is a great base for many cocktails, such as the Old Fashioned, Whiskey Sour, and Boulevardier, as well as creative drinks like the Gold Rush or Penicillin. You can check out our favorite summer whiskey cocktails if you’re craving something seasonal.