Best Bourbon for an Old Fashioned in 2026

Buffalo Trace is a top contender in the Kentucky Bourbon world! Owned by the Sazerac Company, it's one of the biggest bourbon producers, churning out an impressive 2.7 million gallons annually.

Buffalo Trace’s flagship, Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, is considered one of the best Kentucky Bourbons. It’s affordable, packed with flavor, and absolutely worth the price. This well-balanced bourbon offers a classic taste that’s perfect for any occasion. Sip it straight, pour it over ice, or shake it up in your favorite cocktails—it’s that versatile!

This bourbon’s got it all–amazing flavor and a killer decanter design. Aged 8–10 years and bottled at 47% ABV, it brings out a mix of vanilla, sweet corn, cinnamon, and ginger that you’ll notice from the first sniff. 

And at $51.99 for a 750ml bottle, it’s a great deal for anyone who loves well-crafted, flavorful bourbon.

If you’re a beginner and want to develop a greater appreciation for the taste and depth of whiskey, this is the bottle for you. Bottled at 90.4 proof, this whiskey is twice-barreled for an extra rich and vibrant flavor. 

It matures in separate, charred oak barrels in the oldest bourbon distillery in Kentucky. The next nine months involve maturing the mixture in new, deeply toasted and lightly charred barrels. This process transforms the taste by adding an entirely new layer of depth to the drink’s expression. 

Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Bourbon Whiskey is definitely on the more affordable side. It’s a fantastic whiskey for beginners, especially for those who want greater depth and texture in their drinks without breaking the bank completely. 

Elijah Craig’s Small Batch Bourbon is a prime example of the best small batch bourbon. Coming from one of the oldest distilleries in the U.S., Heaven Hill in Kentucky, this bourbon is well-known for its rich smokey oak flavor, which is the result of the unique small-batch process. It has a mellow, full-bodied taste that’s balanced with notes of vanilla, caramel, and spice.

It’s easy to find at most liquor stores and online, made with a mash bill of 78% corn, 10% rye, and 12% malted barley.

Enhanced by a 12-year age statement and bottled at 50% ABV, this bourbon delivers a rich, bold experience. Its long finish delivers warm caramel sauce and baking spices, making it a perfect choice for those who appreciate robust bourbons. 

Priced at $57.99 for a 750ml bottle, Knob Creek is an exceptional option for anyone looking for a top-notch bourbon.