Larceny Bourbon Review

There’s something special about a good wheated bourbon, and Larceny Bourbon knows exactly how to get it right. The brand has built a cult following with its rich, slightly sweet flavor profile that’s easy to drink. Each sip brings great character–just like the legend behind it (more on that later!). 

This Larceny Bourbon review will take you through all you need to know about this wheat-centric brand. This includes the alcohol content, flavor profile, and the best ways to drink it.

Whether you’re considering picking up a bottle for yourself or sending a seasoned whiskey drinker the perfect gift, our guide has got you covered. 

A Quick Look at Larceny Bourbon

Let’s start with a quick mini-review of Larceny Bourbon:.

• Classification: Wheated Bourbon Whiskey

• Tasting Notes: Buttery caramel, honey, fig, hazelnut, old leather, toasted oak, ginger

• Distillery: Heaven Hill Distillery

• Proof: 92-125 proof (46%-62,5% ABV)

• Pros: Affordable and rich because of the use of wheat instead of rye, long and gentle finish.

• Cons: May be too soft for those who prefer a spicier bourbon with a rye mashbill instead of wheat.

What Is Larceny Bourbon?

The story of Larceny Bourbon involves a bit of mischief and a lot of whiskey. It all started with John E. Fitzgerald, a U.S. Treasury agent with a taste for top-shelf bourbon–and the keys to the best barrels. Instead of guarding them, he took what he wanted, sneaking sips from the finest casks like a true bourbon rebel.

This bold act of larceny is what inspired Larceny Bourbon today: rich and flavorful, with the perfect touch of rebellion.  This bourbon’s mashbill is 68% corn, 20% wheat, and 12% malted barley, which experts mill together. Then, they add Kentucky limestone water and yeast for fermentation. 

This mash is then distilled over several days and turned into whiskey.

Small Batch has a bright copper hue, Barrel Proof is a deep sepia, and Old Fitzgerald is a rich burnished copper. All three are perfect for cocktails, from a Kentucky Mule to an Old Fashioned. We’ll discuss more cocktail options and food pairings later in this review. 

What Is the Alcohol Content of Larceny Bourbon

The Small Batch is 92 proof (46% ABV), the Old Fitzgerald is 100 proof (50% ABV), and Barrel Proof is a little higher at 125 proof (62,5% ABV). 

Flavor Review: What Does Larceny Bourbon Taste Like?

The secret behind the taste of this bourbon lies in its wheat mashbill, which lets the usual spice and punch of bourbon take a backseat. Here’s what each drink in this brand’s arsenal tastes like:

• Small Batch: This drink has a well-rounded, buttery caramel flavor with rich notes of honey and a long, savory finish. It smells of fresh bread and toffee, with just a hint of butterscotch.

• Barrel Proof: This drink will soothe your senses with the taste of rich molasses, fig, and hazelnut and the yummy aroma of roasted bread, maple, and cinnamon. It has a warm, lingering finish that will have you wanting another sip.

• Old Fitzgerald Bottled-in-Bond: This drink combines the taste of crème brûlée with old leather, toasted oak, and ginger, with the aroma of leather, vanilla, subtle cinnamon, and nutmeg. The real kicker is in the mildly peppery finish that perfectly balances out the warmth from each sip. 

Compared to rye-heavy bourbons, these drinks are softer and more well-rounded. This makes them an excellent entry point for those new to bourbon. 

How Should You Drink Larceny Bourbon?

Larceny Bourbon offers versatile drinks that hit the mark in any setting, no matter what you're in the mood for. If you want to enjoy the full depth of each flavor, you can sip it neat or on the rocks to bring out those deeper caramel notes. 

You can also use it as a base for various cocktails, such as Kentucky Mule, Paper Plane, Manhattan, Old Fashioned, Fitzgerald Fizz, and more. You can also pair them with roasted almonds, dried pineapple, and chocolate truffles. If you’re craving a more filling meal, you can add in salmon, barbecue pork, or baked cherry pie. 

Is Larceny Bourbon Any Good?

We're not exaggerating when we say that Larceny Bourbon is one of the best premium wheat-based bourbons you can find, and it comes at an insanely reasonable price. 

It’s especially suitable for anyone who prefers rounder, softer flavors over the bold spice kick of a rye-based bourbon. The sweet and smooth character of each Larceny Bourbon drink makes it incredibly easy to love for both casual drinkers and bourbon enthusiasts. 

Larceny Bourbon Small Batch VS. Larceny Bourbon Barrel Proof

The main difference between these two drinks lies in the alcohol content, with Small Batch at 92 proof (46% ABV) and Barrel Proof at 125 proof (62,5% ABV). We’re fans of both these drinks, but whether you’ll prefer one over the other depends on what exactly you’re looking for. 

If you’re on the lookout for a classic wheat-based bourbon that has a buttery taste with a long, slightly sweet finish, Small Batch is where it’s at. 

On the other hand, if you like your bourbon with more of a kick to it, Barrel Proof is the way to go. It has a warm, lingering finish, but the higher alcohol content leaves more of a burn. 

Is Larceny Bourbon a Good Gift?

Larceny Bourbon can be an outstanding gift for bourbon lovers, especially those who appreciate wheat over rye or those who are looking to try something new. 

The bottle design itself is stylish, with the classic keyhole-shaped cutout that nods to Fitzgerald’s legendary exploits with the best barrels in town. You can get the bourbon lover in your life just the bottle or pair it with our bourbon-of-the-month subscription for the gift that keeps on giving. 

Where Can You Buy Larceny Bourbon?

You can buy Larceny Bourbon at most liquor stores and bars or through Uber Eats and InstaCart. A more convenient option is to make your purchases from Flaviar. 

You can also benefit from crazy good deals and subscription boxes, so make sure to check that out!

How Much Does Larceny Bourbon Cost?

The Larceny Small Batch bottle costs around $23.99, a rather affordable option compared to most whiskeys. The Barrel Proof, however, is priced much higher at $84.99. At restaurants or bars, the price varies according to the location, but you can expect to pay around $12 a pour. 

More Expert Liquor Reviews

If Larceny Bourbon has caught your eye, you’ll want to check out our reviews on Pinhook Bourbon and Buffalo Trace Bourbon too. These bourbons bring their own unique flavors to the table and are definitely worth the sip!

Larceny Bourbon Review Verdict: Is It Worth Trying?

Absolutely. If you enjoy a wheat mash bill over rye for a smoother, slightly sweeter sip, Larceny Bourbon is a solid choice. 

Their most popular product, the Small Batch Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey, perfectly captures why it’s so loved. It’s like a cozy autumn day packed into a bottle of polished copper, with the aroma of warm bread and toffee and flavors of caramel, orange blossom honey, and bread pudding.

Ready to try it? Grab a bottle at Flaviar today and sip your way into some whiskey mischief!