TUTHILLTOWN SPIRITS Reviews

All Tuthilltown Spirits Reviews

Average rating: 7.6/10 (601 votes)

Browse 93 reviews for all Tuthilltown Spirits products. You can find the newest reviews at the top.

Found one that sounds tempting? Click on a bottle to learn more about it. Buy it and have a taste yourself.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Simonas,
Tried it in a bar. Nice vanila and caramel tones and quite smooth on the rocks.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Joel,
Smooth with a lot of carmel.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Hilary,
I liked it. But yes, it is a Baby. Has so much potential. I would appreciate it more if it were aged a bit more, I think.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Michael,
Not great. Heavy cereal and overproofed (and overpriced). Good for cocktails.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Scot,
I drink mine with ice. I loved this. A little sweeter and has a bit of the oak, Carmel and such as you’d expect. I’m getting a little banana, as well. I’ll be getting this one, again!
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
guest,
Popcorn, but in a very good way
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Adam,
Decent mixing Bourbon.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Alex,
Strong on the corn, not a huge fan of the aftertaste.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Bradley,
Unique process results in a unique and likeable flavor
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Michael,
Tastes very young. If that's your thing, I can respect that.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Patrick,
Particularly smooth and sweet. When I added a touch of water, the alcohol bite quieted down and was very good. I agree that the price is on the high end.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Timothy,
Strange and sweet - not bad, but not for me
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Stephen,
Not as sweet as I anticipated. Actually had a bit of an herb-like taste.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Jon,
Would be a good mixing bourbon if it was cheap, but doesn't have enough going on to stand on it's own.
Hudson Manhattan Rye Whiskey
Andilee,
Love the flavors from the corn in this one. Sweet to the nose with a bite at the end. Amazingly unique flavors, definitely worth a try.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Joe,
Yes, it’s very sweet and very smooth and nothing like a ‘typical’ bourbon but I really enjoyed it. No burn at all, considering the slightly-elevated proof. My wife (non-whiskey drinker) even liked it. I’d definitely keep this on hand for a relaxed sip, but I think it’s just too expensive.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Sunni,
Tastes very young and rushed to market. I enjoy a white dog (unaged whiskey) but not at this price point. Was not expecting the weak flavor and strong corn taste at $50-ish per bottle.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Jared,
If you like a sweeter taste to your bourbon, this is a go-to!
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
John,
Sweet up front and subtle bite throughout.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Theodore,
Very sweet. My wife actually enjoyed it. It’s very easy to drink. Flavors just aren’t that I was hoping for. Very corn based. Nothing wrong with that. Just nothing amazing
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Shannon,
Not a fan
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Daniel,
Not a "typical" bourbon, in a good way. Strong finish, mellow taste with sweetness on the back. Warm, complex whiskey that rewards you.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Garison,
Pastry flavor.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Laura,
We enjoy this one because it is local, we stop by the distillery and tasting room once a year or so, and we have some nostalgia for it, but it is not as complex as some others we usually get. It is trying to be soft and sweet but hasn't quite gotten there and still is a bit harsh. We do love some of the small batch liquors they are trying, so I think they are perfecting their craft and will get better over time.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Gavin,
The 100% corn mash bill hurts this whiskey. It’s sweet but will taste youthful and unfinished due to the lack of barley and wheat/rye. For the price, there are options that are worlds better. Pass on this one.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Michael,
OK sipper but tastes a little young...
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
jonathan,
This must be mixed as when I had it with 2 cubes I labored to finish my glass.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Matthew,
Nots of Carmel nice and smooth
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Lucas,
Just got this in my last tasting box and loved it! Will go get a bottle this week.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Brian,
Too much of a corn note for my taste
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Ian,
Hints of cinnamon, dark fruit, and malty flavors. A well balanced whiskey that I like a lot.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Jeanne,
It's okay. Smooth, but too sweet / corn forward for me.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Donald,
Starts as butterscotch finishes as melted plastic. One star might be too much
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Danny,
High corn flavor not much to my liking. Finish too flowery for me. Like bourbons that make a statement. This one not saying much.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Matthew,
Exceedingly too much corn and completely unaged.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Sky,
Nice sipping bourbon. You can taste the corn and has a sweet finish. Would drink again
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Leslie,
This bourbon is really awesome. Delicate flavor, delicious
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Allen,
I don't get it--this has come reliably recommended to me, gets good ratings, etc. But each time I try it, I just taste a metallic, immature (Baby?), off-putting wannabe. The rest of the bottle sits on my shelf, waiting to be mixed or shared with guests who may like it.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Lisa,
On the nose, caramel, sweet corn, vanilla. One of the sweeter whiskeys I've tried. It is thicker on the tongue than most. Slight hug at the end. Very friendly.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
David,
just ok
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Mark,
Do not like
Hudson Manhattan Rye Whiskey
Kat,
strong smoke and oak flavor
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Kendra,
Love it
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Jeremy,
Not smoky. Not sure why people would think that. Good $40 bottle.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Stephen,
Smooth, with a bit of a bite. Great on the rocks.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Matthew,
Thought it would taste better
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Jack,
could maybe be a little sweeter. as it is, great body with a less than perfect finish
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Debrenee,
For being aged in under 24 months, I think this is pretty good. Not as intense of a flavor as other well aged bourbons, but it’s price reflects that. Nevertheless, I wouldn’t mind having this on my shelf. Glad I got to try it!
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Nelo,
An ideal whiskey for the beginner whiskey connoisseur.
Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey
Peter,
I'll give it a five. His doesn't live up to the reviews. Maybe I got a bad batch. I got this because I read it was sweet. It's NOT! Very musty..maybe see corn husks fell in this one? I'd only buy it again in hopes of getting a better batch.