Price, Shipping & Taxes may vary by state and will be recalculated at checkout.
Ratings & Reviews
Member Reviews and Ratings of Skrewball Peanut Butter Flavored Whiskey
Alex,
Excellent mixed with a chocolate liquer.
Cameron,
Fun drink to mix it up a bit. Put 5 drops of chocolate bitters in with 2 fingers and a cube and you have a Reese’s cup.
Kurt,
Imagine eating too many peanut butter cups, drinking dirt cheap Jim Beam, and then barfing that into a bottle. That's Skrewball. Disgusting.
Matthew,
This is a good whiskey, very sweet and peanut buttery. Nice surprise, and a fun one to try
Bud,
I'm not much on flavored whiskeys. But this one makes a good cocktail when mixed with a chocolate liquor. Instant peanut butter cup!
John,
Wonderful flavor.
Matt,
Great with Chocolate Liqueur and milk
Michelle,
I love that this has the nice burn of whiskey but I can drink it on ice and its perfectly sweet... sometimes a little two sweet!
Al,
Def an after dinner sniff. I might pair this with a cigar.
Ryan,
Delicious. Enjoy with some ice after dinner.
Brant,
Whisky with peanut butter. What's not to love. Smooth and delicious on its own or mixed.
Andrew,
Nice sweet whiskey I sip as a dessert. I love the after taste of the peanut butter but not as much as my girlfriend. She force feeds me this cause she loves how kissing me tastes afterwards.
Zach,
Not my favorite too much butter
Mark,
Way better than I thought it would be.
It's too sweet to drink straight, but tastes great mellowed out on ice. Then I did a 50/50 mix with cranberry juice on ice for a PB&J mixed drink and my GF loved it.
BJ,
Lots of peanut butter
Brett,
Very sweet, not something I particularly care for. Family members suggested it so I gave it a shot. Might be okay if mixed in the right cocktail but probably not something I'll purchase again.
Matthew,
Sweet, but not syrupy. Tastes like a whiskey that was fat-washed with creamy peanut butter. Not great, but not bad for a flavored whiskey. Easy to sip, like a dessert whiskey.
Gerard,
Sweet and smooth. Great with a dessert
Eric,
Starts out with a strong delicious peanut butter flavor, finishes with garbage taste on the back of the throat
Lisa,
This is so delish!!! Neat or on the rocks!
Justin,
The taste is perfect for a flavored whisky.
Paul,
Too sweet for me. Nice for a quick sip but too much to be something that I could enjoy as a straight drink.
Daniel,
Sweet caramelly peanut butter! A bit too sweet for a straight sipper for me (not the wife), but would be great as a mixer. Wife had picked up a mini bottle at the store just because and now we will get a full one!
Steve,
This is a really nice dessert drink. It is quite sweet, and very smooth. It's also a fun, unique drink to show people or have them try it.
In addition to peanut butter, the aroma reminds me of movie popcorn butter.
Samantha,
Very sweet, peanut butter flavored whisky. Lingering, oily finish. I found it to be clingly and overly sweet.
Collin,
So delicious
Liam,
About as pleasant as 2020. This is “whiskey” for people who don’t like whiskey.
Joe,
My go-to for my sweet tooth. Delicious...and can be poured over chocolate ice cream for an additional treat.
Stephen,
Very smooth and delicious. I like sweet, so it was perfect for me.
Valorie,
Love love Screwball it is so yummy!
Sara,
Sadly I have a peanut sensitivity, so I can try this whiskey. :(
Sarah,
I love this whiskey! It's certainly not your typical whiskey but the sweetness and roasted peanut taste really makes it taste like a cocktail without the crafting. I love to drink it straight and goes down super smooth.
Sean,
Delicious!!
Jacob,
Tastes just like you want it to - full of peanutty goodness. Very sweet and full bodied peanut flavor does the trick.
Lyshemah,
Definitely will keep this on my bar. Not a fan of whisky but totally in love with this one. On the rock with a splash of coke.
guest,
I love having it ice cold!!
Greg,
Surprisingly good served on the rocks and pairs well with cigars.
Jonathan,
Normally I wouldn't use "fun" to describe Whiskey, but this one is. It's great straight, great iced, and wonderful as a mixer. I try and keep my drinks into one of those categories, but this one fits them all. And as an added bonus, I made home-made ice cream with it - scored again!!
Chris,
It's a peanut butter cup in a glass. Pure dangerous decadence.
Reid,
Fun Whisky that strong on the PB.
Dusty,
It has a strong peanut butter flavor/taste, but very smooth after the initial bite of flavor. Nice on the rocks or as a shot. Not a great (slow) sipping drink because when the water dilutes the flavor it doesn't taste as good. But a great starter to the night cap drink.
Stephen,
It'd like drink peanut-brittle. If you like that, it's just too easy to keep drinking.
Helmut,
Just not a whiskey!
Emilio,
My Girlfriends favorite whiskey, taste of peanut butter is strong and Delicious. A little sweet but nice as a dessert over ice cream. Need to try it.
Kathryn,
Absolutely loved it!! The best alcoholic beverage of anything I’ve ever tried.
Helena,
Incredible smooth, full of great flavor and overall a great whiskey!
WolF,
Scary Smooth
Kevin,
Just like the bottle says. Tastes like taking a shot of peanut butter!
Thomas,
I absolutely love this peanut butter whiskey and I love the brand, it's great in cold brew coffee cocktails.
Edwin,
Totally love this...
Alan,
I love peanut butter so this was a sweet surprise. I use it to flavor cheaper blended whiskey for a hint of peanut butter without all the extra calories. It's like a whiskey liqueur.
Sterling,
A simple candy like taste of peanut butter with no offensive taste of alcohol, an easy going drink to have.
Ed,
If you like the idea of fireball but hate cinnamon and love peanut butter. Very very sweet and good for one or two drinks tops
Geoffrey,
Too sweet for me. Strong peanut better flavor. I add it to my pancake batter.
Brendon,
If you like Peanut Butter you have to try this.
Elizabeth,
Very sweet by itself neat but it becomes interesting when you add a hunk of ice cube, even nicer as an old fashioned. I also tried it with cream and chocolate rum, very yummy. It's quite versatile and was a surprising find. It's definitely one I would share with friends, only because the flavor is unique.
Teri,
had my doubts but this is liquid gold!! so yummy...nice in an old fashioned glass with an ice cube <3
William,
Love it
Daniel,
I like it, good for sipin . I love peanut butter ! Try it on ice cream , great . I give it six !
Adam,
It's .... Weird. I like peanut butter, I like whisky. I don't know if this really works. That being said I could imagine it being solid in the right cocktail.
Benjamin,
Interesting taste but definitely couldn't drink more than a single small glass.
Lisa,
Very strong taste of peanut butter, which I love. Slight burn afterwards, but still not too bad.
guest,
Good flavor. Tastes like a spoon full of peanut butter with a alcohol kick. Just a little too sweet to have more than one glass
Brian,
This is a smooth flavor and great finish.
Brian,
Nothing about this was appealing. Just nothing.
Stephen,
It's like drinking peanut brittle. A fun drink, and easy to drink straight.
guest,
Amazing for shots!
guest,
Good with seltzer
Michael,
Combined with some half and half and Chambord it makes a drink that is like drinking your PB&J.
Todd,
More like a dessert liqueur than a Whiskey. You can taste the whiskey in there though - albeit layered under a fantastic peanut butter taste. Almost butterscotch like in flavor. An excellent after dinner treat.
Brad,
Very peanut buttery, but what do you drink peanut butter with?
Laura,
Peanut Butter is sweet, but not a headache in a glass. Great over ice, or with mixers.
William,
It’s just damn fun to drink! Who doesn’t like peanut butter?
Jordan,
Absolutely delicious, very sweet and nutty and smooth. Don't buy it if you don't like sweet syrupy whiskeys, but if you do this one is delicious, I'm a huge fan.
Janet,
I love this!! I don't think its too sweet it def has a nice nutty taste to it. But watch out it sneaks up on you because it is so good you will drink lots
Jason,
Sweeter than I was thinking. Some people really love it though!!
Jonathan,
I’m not gonna even apologize for how ridiculously delicious this is. Basically Reese’s Pieces in a glass. Don’t @ me.
Valorie,
Love love it!!! very easy to keep enjoying lol I use coffee ice cubes and some whipping cream yum!
Janet,
love the ice cube idea!!!
Alex,
A total gimmick but totally fun. Plays well with other spirits.
Salvatore,
I love this. Amazing flavor! Can’t drink a lot, but a shot really hits the spot. Unexpected surprise.
John,
Awesome with equal parts of heavy whipping cream in the silver bullet
Michael,
Want a PB flavored whiskey? You found it. It’s good, this is not my first bottle. Don’t? Then don’t get this.
guest,
Smelled like I just opened a jar of peanut butter! Very nutty and sweet taste. Very good sipping whiskey for someone with a sweet tooth.
Phil,
A little sweet but not too much.
kara,
Very sweet. I am not great at mixed drinks but I bet it is amazing in a great mixologists hands. Was really good with mocha as an Irish coffee.
James,
Awesome mixed with Godiva Choclate Liqueur
JASON,
The flavor was spot on. Had a great nose and held the flavor all the way through. Would have rated higher but it was just too sweet. It had a thick, almost syrup texture. Makes for a nice dessert sipping drink but I couldn’t drink more than that. Great flavor but overall just ok.
Katrinia,
its not bad for a novelty whiskey. REALLY sweet.
Rusty,
Great flavor! Works well neat or on the rocks. Wonderful whiskey for mixing cocktails and shots!!
Jay,
A bit too sweet and not as peanut buttery as I'd hoped. I tasted it in there really deep in the flavor, but if you mix it that's kind of lost. I've tried it with several things such as creme de cacao and that was even sweeter and whatever cdc I bought at the local store was very "fake chocolate" tasting so not that good either and again very sweet. It may need some creme to mellow all that out or something when mixed. Just tried some in my mocha coffee and that wasn't too bad.
Owen,
I love it
Matthew,
Surprisingly pleasant
Michael,
As someone who isnt a big fan of whiskey, particularly whiskey straight, I was blown away by this new kid on the block. A strong flavor of peanut butter at the front and just a little kick at the back. Perfect for a night out next to the fire.
Tom,
Too sweet for me but can be a desert sipper in a pinch.
Jack,
Not my "everyday" drink, more of a novelty drink when mixed with either Godiva Chocolate Liqueur or some creme de cacao for a "peanut butter cup'.
guest,
Best flavored whiskey!!!
guest,
Flavor
RAYMOND,
Did not have pnt btr taste
Linda,
More of a butterscotch flavor than peanut butter. Sweet and tasty. A dessert drink.
David,
Good fun mixer that’s about it
Kayla,
It is good but drinks more like a liqueur due to the high sugar and low alcohol content (as well as mouthfeel and viscosity). More of a sweet peanut flavor than actually peanut butter but certainly does capture the essence. It does have that nice warming spiciness of a whiskey, though. My rating reflects judgement against what it is versus what it is supposed to be -- not rated against all other whiskeys in absolute.
Jake,
Definitely more of a liqueur than whiskey. It is a unique flavor with a lot of sweetness but a good addition to my bar. It makes a very different old fashioned, that's for sure
Bradley,
I cannot get paste the sweet sickening taste. I have never been repulsed by a whiskey in my life like Skrewball. Do not buy. If someone offers a sample give it a try and say been there done that, never again.
Martin,
Definitely different and in a very good way.
Todd,
Blend it with vanilla ice cream and make a great adult milk shake.
guest,
Amazing!! I never imagined that peanut butter and whiskey could go together....but this is like dessert!
Jake,
A unique flavor to add to a whiskey. A bit sweeter than I would have liked but makes a good old fashioned and you can drink it neat without so much as a grimace. Definitely more liqueur than whiskey.
Chris,
I highly enjoyed the taste. It’s to sweet for a sipper. But as a shot or paired with chocolate ice cream it’s amazing. My wife is head over heels with it as well.
Doug,
The flavor of this stuff is exactly what the label indicates: a peanut butter flavored whiskey. Overall, the whiskey is pretty sweet, and it is hard to consume large amounts in a single setting.
Kimberlee,
This was surprisingly good. Had hints of caramel and a smooth finish. Will definitely buy again.
guest,
Not great. I wouldn’t buy it.
AJ,
I was surprised by the level of sweetness, but it was so smooth that I’m loving it!!
I label this as dangerous it’s so good
Todd,
We did a blind taste test with a few peanut butter whisky entries and this was the HANDS DOWN favorite! Toss some into a hot cocoa for a liquid peanut butter cup. Perfect for a winter night.
Nicolle,
I am really in love with this. It is so smooth and easy to drink and not too much on the sweet side. Its only missing the one star because it tastes more like caramel or butterscotch than peanut butter but still buying 2 at a time from now on!
guest,
Jumped right to my #1 go to all around!
Kenyada,
Very smooth! Not too sweet! Amazing flavor
Kathryn,
So glad I asked my local store owner about this and bought a sample. He recommended to put it in the freezer then pour a drink over a single ice cube which is just fantastic. I love another reviewers recommendation for a twist on a white russian . . .I'll be trying that today and buying this regularly.
Spencer,
Love it! Saving the bottle as a reminder to the future that I have to order more for family occasions.
frank,
I didnt know what to expect with this, but WOW was i surprised when i tasted it. I LOVED THIS!!!! Then I mixed it with Mountain Dew and it got even better!!!
frank,
I just ordered 3 more bottles I liked it that much
Mark,
Tell me more about Mountain Dew mixed with this??
Michael,
Very nice, smooth tasting and lingers for a while after sipping.
Jeff,
I was very surprised at the amount of peanut butter flavor came through. I thought it was similar to the taste of a liquer. One of my favorites
Tyler,
Amazing whiskey with awesome flavor. One of my favorite whiskeys to drink it’s great straight on the rocks or mixed. My favorite is mixing it with Kahlúa and mike for a nice twist on a White Russian!
julie,
Allow me to say, I am NOT a whiskey fan, that being said a friend of mine told me to try this. I AM a peanut butter fan, and I will admit the thought of the 2 mixed together was unappealing. I found this to be smooth, easily drinkable, no aftertaste, and just the right taste of peanut butter without overwhelming whiskey flavor. I agree that on the rocks is probably best! I would purchase again!
Ryan,
Much too sweet. The PB taste is strong and almost overwhelming. Someone tried too hard and should have dialed it back a bit. Might make a decent party shot, but needs a partner to be a winner.
Stephanie,
What a great flavor of peanut butter and a hint of coffee! Very smooth and just the right amount of sweetness. Not thick and no after taste.
Antti,
It is a rich, flavored Whiskey that has a rich & aromatic birth; while a rich & bold life leads to an extra long & thick death with notes of caramel candy & butterscotch.
Anne,
super sweet
Paul,
I thought this was delicious and drank it neat. I would definitely recommend this to anyone who likes peanut butter. It was a little thicker than anticipated but I think I liked it more because of this.
Steve,
This stuff is surprisingly good! Makes an excellent PB&J Old Fashioned :)
Spencer,
Perfect for those that love peanut butter including myself and the family!
Meredith,
This very good if you like peanut butter. I enjoy sweets so this was right up my alley. Smooth and sweet.
Mark,
With a nose of buttered popcorn, this is an interestingly sweet component to a PB & J Old Fashioned from 38 degrees!
jill,
Like a peanut butter cookie in a bottle. Sweet but not cloying like Crown Royal Maple. Similar sweetness to Crown Royal Apple/Peach.
Chad,
Amazing flavor. Reese’s peanut butter cup fans will love this!
Cory,
You really gotta love peanut butter sweets to enjoy this one. It tasted very much like butterscotch. They hit that note square on the head, and it was smooth. Too sweet for me. If I were to drink something that sweet, I'll stick to a cocktail.
christopher,
Really Nice Sipping Whisky!
Campbell,
Made right in my town. It is a great desert whiskey and is great cold or over ice cream
Richard,
This is a great sipping whiskey, add some chocolate bitters and it's a dangerous dessert.
Egan,
The peanut butter flavor is good, not too strong. It was very yummy to sip.
George,
Different and great flavour. The peanut butter isn’t too subtle but I don’t feel it’s too over powering. I don’t think I could drink multiple glasses in a night, but it’s an awesome drink that changes things up. It was also very good in a cold coffee.
Josh,
Has more of a butterscotch taste than a peanut butter taste. Somewhat disappointed.
Brian,
This is not good. It tasted like whiskey with peanut butter syrup. Maybe it would be okay poured over ice cream...
Cory,
Agreed!
Cinthea,
Unexpected flavor. Friends loved it. Smooth. Will buy again.
Bruce,
I mean, it tastes scrumptious. Not at all like a whiskey. More like something high schoolers drink. But what will I feel like tomorrow? What else is in this thing?
Lysander,
It tastes more like a cordial infused with skippy than a whiskey.
Back
