Rum Reviews

All Rum Reviews

Average rating: 8.1/10 (26301 votes)

Browse 4,035 reviews for all Rum products. You can find the newest reviews at the top.

Found one that sounds tempting? Click on a bottle to learn more about it. Buy it and have a taste yourself.
Matusalem 15 Gran Reserva Solera Rum
David,
Smooth sweet caramel flavour love it by the far best rum I ever had
Brugal 1888 Rum
Saville,
Really liked this rum. Smooth flavor, easy to mix and enjoy over ice. It's going to make a great Xmas gift for a friend!
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva
Kenji,
Sweet, smooth with no bite. Has a cinnamon flavor without the becoming spicy.
Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Maria,
Loved this Rum.
Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Rodrigo,
Very easy to drink and very smooth, with a great vanilla taste. Love it.
Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Eskil,
Too much vanilla for my taste.
Dictador 20 Year Old Solera System Rum
Brian,
Honey maple nose with a sweet hint but turns a little dry and spicy at the finish.
Grander 8 Year Old Rum
Brian,
Dry and spicy. Burned more than I like.
Brugal 1888 Rum
jonathan,
it's got notes of whiskey flavors, but from a scotch/whiskey drinker... this is still very much a sweet tasting rum.
Matusalem 15 Gran Reserva Solera Rum
Mat,
sweet caramel and vanilla aromas. really nice caramel flavour to this, lacks a bit of depth and complexity but given the price this is a really good value sipping rum.
Dictador 20 Year Old Solera System Rum
Debbie,
Incredibly smooth, sweet, bold, balanced and flavorful. One of the best I’ve tasted. EXCELLENT for sipping!! I’m going out and getting this bottle after sampling it. Will make a great addition to our collection.
Dictador 20 Year Old Solera System Rum
Ron,
Wow not expecting the dry, not so sweet taste after nosing. At nose, completely get the honey and maple. Mouth is slight spice, not overly smoky with the oak. Finish without burn or warmth, clean...no ice.
Gold of Mauritius Dark Rum
Karl,
Warm, sweet, smooth aromas of banana, milk chocolate and toffee. A lovely dark rum that both me and the people I was drinking it with really enjoyed. Will definetly be getting this again once the bottle is empty!
El Dorado 12 Year Old
Greg,
Really enjoyed both straight and mixed. Will definitely get again.
Bumbu The Original Rum
Greg,
Was a bit to sweet for my liking. Definitely needed a mixer. Glad I tried it, but not a fan.
Brugal 1888 Rum
Eric,
Nice stuff.
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva
Eric,
Smooth and perfectly sweet.
Brugal 1888 Rum
jonathan,
accurately described as a bridge between whisky and rum. definitely rum forward, with flavors of oak and smoke and other whisky flavors. but for a whisky drinker, it doesnt have the bite.
Dictador 20 Year Old Solera System Rum
Eric,
Smooth and delicious. Delicious molasses notes on the finish.
Brugal 1888 Rum
Roger,
Super smooth with an oak taste that's not too strong. Great on it's own or mixed
El Dorado 12 Year Old
Gregory,
Was not my favorite. After taste was not appealing. If you want a rum with a kick but no sweetness at all you will like this one. About as close to bourbon as you can get.
Mount Gay Eclipse
Michael,
Good flavor but pretty harsh. Would use in a mixed drink.
Tanduay Asian Rum Gold
Fallon,
Smooth butterscotch flavor Earthy forward Finishes sweet
Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Kenn,
Very sweet. Possibly too much... trying this in the sampler size. Neat first, then on the rocks. The ice cut the sweetness a bit. Very candy vanilla orange. I could grow to like this, but not as the regular go-to.
Ron Esclavo XO Rum
Mortimer,
Caramel and Spicy flavors, warm and sweet taste ! Very good in Automn !
Brugal 1888 Rum
Melanie,
My knowledge of rum is not tremendous, but I really enjoyed this bottle. Very smooth on its own, both neat and with a bit of ice. It also made an excellent Dark and Stormy.
Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Miguel,
Smooth drink, easy sip.
Papa's Pilar Dark Rum
Christopher,
My first glass, I wasn’t all that impressed. It was good, but not a “wow”. The second and subsequent, I really got to enjoying this. Will definitely be purchasing again.
Brugal 1888 Rum
Steven,
Simply DELICIOUS sipping rum. Wonderful on its own
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva
Tyler,
Sweet and smooth. Easy to drink neat.
Diplomatico Ambassador
Timothy,
From this Rummy to you, this is THE BEST rum ever created by humans. It's rather pricey for it disappears too fast. It is incredibly smooth and very flavorful. Truly delicious for all your senses.
Pusser's Blue Label
Jude,
Ok so this is my problem, drinking it straight over ice. Can’t do it. Looking at the flavor spiral makes me wish i had looked before i bought it from the store. leather, tobacco and oak? THEN spicy? Never again.
La Hechicera Fine Aged Rum
George,
Outstanding!
Diplomatico Ambassador
George,
It is a decent sipping rum but I prefer something sweeter. Not worth the cost in my opinion!
Brugal Añejo
Tim,
Smooth but strong
STOLEN Overproof Rum
Adam,
Very strong but amazing
Diplomático Reserva Exclusiva
Steve,
Very smooth and tasty. Love it straight up on the rocks. Probably the best rum I have had.
Dos Maderas PX 5YO + 5YO Rum
Roy,
Really smooth and easy to drink.
Brugal 1888 Rum
Robert,
Love this rum with Coke
Grander 8 Year Old Rum
John,
Rubbing alcohol
Dictador 20 Year Old Solera System Rum
John,
Sweet and nice flavor. Smooth
Dictador 20 Year Old Solera System Rum
Emma,
Delicious maple, nutty flavor. It’s a real treat
El Dorado 15 Year Old
Matt,
A really delicious rum, but IMO it is bested by the less expensive 12-year and of course by the significantly more expensive 21 year. This is still a great rum, just not worth the premium over the 12.
Don Papa Small Batch Rum
Stephen,
Very moreish, lovely to drink over ice, big hit of vanilla with toffee and butterscotch. I will definitely buy another bottle, I wouldn’t mind trying any of the others in the range!
Gold of Mauritius Dark Rum
Aleksandras,
Lovely earthy flaviours.
Brugal 1888 Rum
Dalia,
Smooth rum, enjoyable, subtle oak flavor. A great mixer
Bumbu The Original Rum
Preston,
Wayyyyyy too sweet and banana flavor overwhelms everything else.
Spytail Black Ginger Rum
Stephen,
Funky bottle but contents are quite tasty... either straight or in a cocktail. My preferred mixed drink is a variation on the dark and stormy....sometimes using bourbon....but this is my favorite along with the oft out of stock Hercules Milligan. Price escalation is noticable however.
Brugal 1888 Rum
Gene,
Very good rum with a nice balance of oak and vanilla with a smooth and somewhat sweet finish. I mixed this with fresh Apple Cider and it made for a nice fall drink. I will definitely order this again.
Gold of Mauritius Dark Rum
Michael,
We went to Mauritius about ten years ago so ordered this rum out of nostalgia. The first sip was a delight to the taste buds. It was smooth and warm with just a hint of vanilla. The first bottle did not last long and since finishing it we have ordered six more bottles, some as Christmas Gifts for Rum loving friends.