Rum Reviews
All Rum Reviews
Browse 2,187 reviews for all Rum products. You can find the newest reviews at the top.
Found one that sounds tempting? Click on a bottle to learn more about it. Buy it and have a taste yourself.
Found one that sounds tempting? Click on a bottle to learn more about it. Buy it and have a taste yourself.
Jason,
This smells like classic rum, reminds me of a rum tobacco I used to smoke. Lovely fig Newton flavor that lingers long. Might gift myself some, but a bit heavy and expensive for my rotation
Steven,
Too sweet for my taste, in defense of the Bottle I should have read the description more closely, I would not have ordered it if I had realized it was a "Spiced Rum"
Simon,
Not an easy rum to drink! I was not impressed with how rough this rum felt.
John,
Great siping rum. Loved the sweet (but not too sweet) taste and the slight bite at the end. Definitely a favorite.
Richard,
Great rum! One of my favorites to drink straight. Definitely going to buy this one again.
Richard,
Strong alcohol smell. Not as smooth as other rums I enjoy. definitely not my favorite and I wouldn’t buy it again.
Richard,
Strong vanilla/butterscotch smell. Smooth taste, not too sweet. Good to drink straight on ice. Wouldn’t recommend mixing it.
guest,
Excellent rum! Preferably neat. Very smooth with a very noticeable coconut finish. Highly recommend!
Captain,
Delicious, sweet but not too sweet. Good flavor and I thought it was smoooooth.
Carlos,
Great for mixing. Sweet & spice with a nice finish. Good with Coke no more than two ice cubes.
Amanda,
The smokiness of this treat played in on a huge flavor benefactor for my tastes buds! Very intriguing. A big toast to Stolen Smoked Rum!
Aaron,
It can be good neat, but thins out too much if you cocktail with it. I can list quite a few rums I would prefer over this, especially for the price. Not worth it.
Warrick,
Basic rum with a decent finish. Would be nice for mixing but too good for shots.
austin,
A bit too sweet for my taste. Smooth, overly sweet, taste like a liquid butterscotch candy.
shawn,
I bought 2 bottles as gifts and wish I would of bought one for myself. My buddies and I agreed this was the best rum we'd ever had. We drank it neat. Pair it with a good cigar and BOOM... mind blown.
Jeff,
Great smell, great taste. Very smooth, but not sweet. I usually like my rum a bit sweeter, but this was a nice change of pace. It tasted and felt almost dry, but went down smooth.
Michelle,
The perfect rum. Not too sweet. Not too strong. Perfect notes of spices.
Robert,
I feel the same way , not as good as the St. Kitts bottle from the Islands , sorry to say , made in Rochester , NY
Danny,
Great sipping Rum, they also have a in house exclusive 4 star thats phenomenal!
George,
Not quite what I call rum. But rather enjoyable if one was looking for a ginger beer- orange zest and soda mix. As one who prefers their drink neat and room temp ,his is not it.
Gary,
Smooth, a hint is sweet. This is a wonderful sipping rum
Danny,
My favorite rum to sip. It’s the Goldilocks, not too sweet, not too dry. If you don’t like this, rum isn’t for you.
Harvey,
Great rum for the price. Smooth and rich in flavor this is a real best but.
Charles,
This is one of the smoothest, interesting drink I have had so far. I had to be careful not to get into the bottle. Then I realized I had almost finished half the bottle.
Ken,
A nice sipping rum, sweet but not overly sweet. For the price I would go with Ron Zacapa 23, but that is just me.
Troy,
Avoided because I thought it was a gimmick. Then I tried it. This is a great, well-rounded rum good either on it's own or mixed. Likely to become my go-to rum at home. Gimmick or not, this is a winner.
Eric,
very unique rum that does not follow other rum tastes. Has a apple aftertaste that makes it a one of a kind. Not the top of my list but has its place in the bar.
Eric,
Awesome sweet and spicy rum. I could be in trouble with this one and need to order some more.
Michael,
Great old school flavor sip or mix enjoyed will be a repeat purchase 👍🏻
Andre,
Absolutely love it!!!!! Very smooth drinking. Starts off with hints of vanilla and finishes with a little spice. Wish I would have purchased two bottles. Definitely recommend.
Antti,
It is a classic, rich, Dark Rum in which the solera styleaged for at least 21 years with a rich birth; while a dry & mellow life that leads to a long & rich death.
Joe,
Beautiful sipping rum. Super smooth, sweet, earthy, maybe a touch of smoke, and some citrus on the finish just to be interesting. Lovely and relaxing on the waterfront in Old San Juan!
Warrick,
By far one of the best Rums I have tasted... Must have!
guest,
Cocoa rum! Full of Body and rly sweet, but not as Diplomatico Reserva Exclusiva. Caramel, Brown Sugar + Cocoa, great for sipping without rocks.
guest,
Really Sweeet! In first taste - oak and walnuts, but after taste is full of brown sugar, liquer, caramel and candies! Great for slow sipping.
Ariella,
I really enjoyed this rum, it smelled sweet and had some sweetness in the taste. To be honest I'm new to this; so vague details is all I got. Plus, I haven't really tasted enough of others to rate this rum properly, however saying all that, in this current time and place I stand by my rating.
