- Help
- About
- Contact us
- Partnerships
- Careers
- Terms & Conditions
- Shipping & Returns
- Refund Policy
- Privacy Policy
- Press
- Blog
CATOCTIN CREEK Reviews
All Catoctin Creek Reviews
Browse 59 reviews for all Catoctin Creek products. You can find the newest reviews at the top.
Found one that sounds tempting? Click on a bottle to learn more about it. Buy it and have a taste yourself.
Found one that sounds tempting? Click on a bottle to learn more about it. Buy it and have a taste yourself.
Michael,
I was excited for this, having enjoyed rye gins I have found previously, but it's just terrible. It has an overwhelming note and after taste of licking an envelope. It's not undrinkable, but it's not worth drinking.
Russell,
Good sipping Rye. A little harsh neat, but perfect on the rocks. Would recommend it for people who enjoy whiskey on the rocks.
Brendan,
Had an off-putting fruitiness to it neat, but made an amazing old-fashioned. Unfortunately, it's a bit too expensive as a mixer and it doesn't hold up as a sipper.
Joshua,
Fantastic sipping. Mello with enough rye to add a bit of fire. Not overly complex but an excellent price for what you get. And what you get is a Rye with balance, and flavor.
Alan,
This is one of the best Rye Whiskeys out there for the price. Everything is sourced close to the distillery.
Joe,
Great carmel aroma. I liked it before the glass hit my lips. The 58% was more than welcome as I sampled it as a nightcap.
As others have noted I think it will be best enjoyed with a splash of water or over ice.
Robert,
Wonderful rye. Spicy with a clean finish.
Renee,
Not for me. No aroma to speak of. Oily, medicinal taste when neat. Reasonable with lots of water.
Robert,
Such a nice, deliciously smooth, caramel start with subtle, fruity, raisin finish. A great addition.
Richard,
This one seems a bit watered down. I wish I would have started with this tasting, it would have been a good #1.
Joe,
Not as spicy as other rye whiskeys and a bit smoother than most. Maybe even a little sweet? I really enjoyed this. Honestly I don’t get the harsh flavors that many people here have noted.
John,
Smooth, well made, young rye. You can't go wrong with the Roundstone Rye. Scott and Becky make some good stuff!
Marguerite,
Fantastic! Spicy and hot (alcohol) with a strong Caramel noise and finish
Matt,
Goes down smooth and has good flavor. I enjoy it on the rocks.
Steven,
Honestly, I was skeptical when trying this. I wasn’t sure about rye having not liked a couple others that I have tried in the past. This spirit has opened the door to rye. It’s definitely the best I’ve had and will be branching out into others now. Thanks Flaviar
Matt,
Really good stuff. Goes down smooth. I prefer it on the rocks.
Matt,
I don't like gin, but this wasn't bad at all. I thought of this as 90% gin and 10% whiskey.
Matt,
Really good stuff. Goes down smooth. I prefer it on the rocks.
Victor,
A fairly sweet Rye that still has the characteristic spicy finish that I love in a good Rye. All in All an extremely good spirit especially for those new to Rye Whiskey.
Elizabeth,
Complex. Initially a bit harsh but finishes well.
Kris,
Solid but a little to aggressive and a not quite enough on the finish
Daniel,
I’ve had a few bottles of this whiskey over the years. The evolution of this fairly young distillery has been an interesting ride. I enjoyed every bottle. This is an easy sipping rye.
Christopher,
Pretty good Rye. Good fruit and vanilla flavoring, no hard done looked some other Ryes. Better on the tongue then on the nose.
Gordon,
Not too bad, not too good. Middle of the road that really leaves me with little to say. Butter and bread notes are strong. Smell is almost overpowering.
Justin,
It is a fairly smooth rye. I have had better rye's for sure, but very drinkable. It kind of tastes like drinking a loaf of bread.
James,
Caramelized sugar start, mild middle and a short finish.
Justin,
Smells disgusting but the flavor is very smooth and crisp. Slightly bad aftertaste but still pretty good.
Chris,
A very nature driven aroma, beautiful. light lemon, buttery and caramel taste. After taste is good, felt like I took a bite out of a loaf. Not so long lasting or as spicy as I prepared for, but a good glass of whiskey for sure.
Michael,
Juniper with underlying lavender on the nose. Flavors start sweet and floral up front, progressing to juniper, pepper, cinnamon and licorice. Finish is long and semi-dry with juniper, citrus rind and a bit of grain character. It's 100 proof nature lends it a nicely warm (but not harsh) burn. A nice contemporary gin, while still having a classical juniper backbone. Makes a very crisp G&T.
Michael,
Not terrible for a rye - but there certainly are better ones. This is excellent for mixing.
JUSTIN,
Nice smooth whiskey. Will be buying again.
Tomasz,
Nice, smooth rye with some surprising minty notes. Nothing groundbreaking but an easy sipper.
Don,
Really nice! I am a scotch drinker but this was a pleasant surprise in the tasting department. It was a solid performer throughout the drink.
William,
4 stars with water. Initially tastes like acetone. Water opens up the aroma and flavor, giving it a more rye bread and woody taste. Very strong finish.
Tom,
My absolute go-to for cocktails and neat rye alike.
guest,
send sample today////i can,t rate it if i can,t taste it < sampleplease
