Price, Shipping & Taxes may vary by state and will be recalculated at checkout.
Ratings & Reviews
Member Reviews and Ratings of Caol Ila 12 Year Old
Randall,
Very similar to Compass Box Peat Monster. Lots of smoke and peat.
Jan,
Probably I've come across a bad bottle. Too overpowering on the alcohol side, almost tongue-numbing. Not many flavors to be distinguihed. A very distant peat in there, but hardly a favorite.
Craig,
A very good drinker when you’ve had a bad day or a good day at work. A cube of ice and you’re on your way to a good relaxing evening. Beautiful flavours and a smooth taste that changes as you drink it more. A definite one to have permanently stocked in your home bar!!
Inderjeet,
Although I'm not a big fan of smoky whiskey, this specific one went down well. There was a strong after taste many would like, if they prefer a smokier whiskey. I particularly enjoyed the colour, which was light and golden and noticed a few legs along the glass. Overall its not something I'll try again but recommend for fans of smoky tasting whiskey.
Natalie,
My husband and I were both really looking forward to tasting this one because we both love peaty Islay single malts. We both thought it was just ... ok. Neither of us got much peat at all, although I definitely got grassiness which I thought was the most interesting thing about it. I didn’t finish drinking my sample.
David,
Before getting into Lagavulin 16, I wanted to try this one out for my first whiskey on the heavy peat end. Not usually a peat fan, but I am slowly growing into it. Earthy peat, sweet notes, vanilla and spice with the smoke lingering at the end. Gonna have to sit with this one as peat is one of those like it/hate it kind of things.
Derrick,
Lovely Isaly whisky.
Michael,
Very approachable but distinct Islay Scotch. Great for beginners due to smoothness of finish.
Nicholas,
Caol Ila is the kind of affordable Islays. It doesn't get any better than this.
Niko,
Ok
Orlando,
Smokey earthy taste followed by sweet candy notes. Really fun to drink. It's great.
Nicki,
Peaty yet smooth!
Alex,
Great sipping Islay. Peaty but gentle, sweet pears and fabulous mouthfeel
Joshua,
Very solid Scotch! Love the level of smoke in this one!
Adam,
A very enjoyable drink. I was unsure about the hint of smokiness at first but I now find the flavour addictive. Very easy to drink and well worth the cost.
dr,
some years ago, I had a 10yo Caol Ila and my abiding memory was the overpowering sense of phenol. I had 30yo bottle as well and when i got home from the experience i had to savour the elderly gentleman. This 12yo reminds me more of the elder than the younger. I was extremely pleasantly surprised. thank you
Connor,
This is quite possibly my favorite Scotch. It's what converted me to Scotch away from gin. The smoke, the peat, the easy finish. It's so luxurious and yet so non-pretentious. I love this stuff!
Nadav,
Wonderful expression of peaty whisky, because of the wonderful complexity with sweetness, fullness and smoke.
Santiago,
Not Disappointment here!!. I was looking forward to taste this one, after I have seen many reviews. It was hard for me to go away from the smoky flavor from the smell all the way to the finish. Nevertheless, I have enjoyed once I was able to get some of the sweetness as well.
Mason,
The phenols are off-putting for me, but it's stills good. The smoke is great I just prefer different Islay for when I'm in that mood.
Zane,
This did not disappoint. As advertised, it is smokey with a little sweetness. Big time flavor.
Giampaolo,
The pleasure of drink, After a little glass, another little glass. unbelievable
Matt,
Smoky and peaty but not overwhelming. Balanced flavor from beginning to end.
Ronan,
Smoket with a sweetness going through it. Light in colour and delicate. Quite nice.
Antti,
It is an outstanding, intense, Single Malt Scotch Whisky that has an aromatic birth; while a rich & smoky life leads to a long, warm & spicy death with notes of white pepper & cinnamon.
Chris,
Loved it. A great expression by Caol Ila; however, the lagavullin 16 is like for like price and my preferred.
Roy,
Makes an evening very enjoyable!
Stjepan,
I like the smoothness and the peaty aftertaste.
Josh,
I prefer sherry cask Scotch but I must say this is absolutely wonderful. Nice smooth smoke with a mildly sweet, earthy finish. Excellent, almost a 10!
Dougal,
A classic Caol Ila, Smokey but not overwhelming with a nice sweet finish..not one for the start of the night but for a peat fan, it's sure to go well.
Davide,
Cull-eela
Lloyd,
Definitely not for my palate, very heavy dram with strong peat and smokiness, goes down like lead balloon.
Michał,
Fantastic, not too smokey and rich flavoured.
Tammy,
Wonderfully smokey with some orange and saltiness
Andrew,
Love the peaty flavours, intense but delightfully so.
Stijn,
Realy pleasant. Peaty, salty. Touch of vanilla
sean,
Beautiful flavours, definitely need another bottle or something similar
Jeremy,
Wonderfully pleasant Islay dram
guest,
Very smoky and peaty on the nose, just how I like it. Initial taste is also smoky and peaty, but later gives way to subtle sweet vanilla and spice. Finishes with a lingering pepper flavor.
Eric,
Good tasting whiskey. On the lighter side, notes of smoke and possibly even a hint of bacon. Some sweet flavors as well underneath.
Michael,
Sweet, spicy, then smoky, but not insanely peaty. Very nice, very smooth.
Daniel,
Peat. Tobacco. Incense.
Szymon,
I’m a beginner and tried this for first time. Really liked the smoke and was able to taste and smell some fruit like apple and pear. First time I enjoyed a whiskey neat!
Pontus,
Smooth and smokey with an great smokey aftertone.
Nathan,
Light sea salt, cinnamon & peat on the nose.
Vanilla cream icing, oily pallet
Moderate peppery finish.
guest,
Peaty, light on the tongue and nutty finish
Kerr,
Good peaty
Kevin,
Subtle smoke, subtle peat, a balance for the mood with a little of either
Joshua,
For someone who's experience with Scotch Whisky has been limited to JW, I have to say I might be a single malt man! Really easy to drink with an awesome finish!
Clark,
Maybe my favourite Whisky so far - I am not super experienced, but have tried about 25 different whiskys in the past 2 years. My wife, who has never tried a cigarette or cigar, thinks this is why people like to smoke after a meal. Really smoky and satisfying.
ALEXANDER,
Smooooooth. Nice mouthfeel, great sipper after a long day.
Karri,
New year present from a good friend.
Very smooth experience, with happy surprise with the flavors. This one was much welcome addition to my collection.
Paul,
Way too much peat for my taste... that’s all I could taste or smell. Overpowering
Piotr,
Oh... ohhh... what a taste!!! Wonderful!
Eric,
I'm am NOT a peat fan, yet the Caol Ila 12 works for me. It's like the max level of peat someone who doesn't like peat would actually enjoy.
Eric,
My favorite dram after a day of smoking brisket....heaven
guest,
Bru cafe nijmegen
Jason,
Much peatier up front than I thought it would be, but the peat and smoke give way to a fruity, mellow back with a smooth finish.
Michael,
Amazing. Melon nose with smoke. A much lighter, fruitier Islay. Tingly mouth finish of mint.
Charles,
Yes, as good as the hype. Feels similar to Lagavulin 8.....if your British thing Curly Wurly
Anders,
Nose: smoke, sulfur, citric notes. Wet, burnt wood, old seaweed
Palate: Christmas cake. Spices and oaky bitterness. Not overly complex
Finish: oak and more spices. A hint of citrus. Medium long
Qi,
Peat it
Matthew,
Nice and sturdy, but not as well-rounded as Laphroaig 10. It’s almost like it’s missing something...
Todd,
Nice floral with a touch of peat aroma, but not overpowering. This is quite good, a bit of peat, some spice and some herbal as well. Smooth without any water. A dash of water does seem to bring out the spice a bit more. It also seems to enhance the floral aroma. Would buy this one again.
James,
Very peaty with antiseptic and slight saltiness. An outstanding representation of Islay whiskey.
James,
One of my a time favorites
Jimmy,
Very woodsy and earthy. Smooth and light going down. But I’m not a fan of Peat Whisky. An acquired taste definitely not for me
Jeffrey,
Not my cup of tea but I respect that it’s good tea.
vincent,
Smoky, last glass was enjoyed with some nice chocolate.
One that got better with every glass more and more flavors stood out with a drop of water or some whisky stones
Gašper,
Oily, very likeable
Daniils,
Great taste and scent. One of the best bottles I tried for this price range. Totally reccomend that to all Islay lovers.
Dorn,
Good nice price Islay Whiskey
Günter,
It‘s got the typical Islay Taste, albeit a bit weaker than the famous Islay Scotches. Enjoyed it anyway
Bob,
A nice peaty, smoky Islay Scotch. Certainly not for everyone. I was able to taste cinnamon, which was a nice touch.
Steve,
Nice scotch. Ok when I opened the bottle, flavor grew on me (improved) as I finished the bottle. Good stuff, definitely would buy again.
Joseph,
At 1st I was not impressed, but as I drank the bottle it grew on me. I feel this is a more certificated version of the Talisker 10
Imran,
well balanced Peat with Sweet. Not crazy smoke but right amount. Sweet from bourbon barrels.
Lawrence,
Peat and smoke love. Phenols calm a bit with water. Oily cinnamon and spice. Nice finish
William,
A classic Islay scotch!
David,
One of the best I’ve try the flavor the smoke to it I love it
Elizabeth,
Smooth and a little smoky
Shaun,
Love this smoky whiskey
Rene,
Unfortunately bit too strong for my taste.
Taylor,
This is everything I love about whisky in a single dram!
Joe,
Like it
Halldor,
After a few drops of water were added, it was a really nice tasting glass!
Sei-IS,
Anything above 8 for me means pleating and smokey with a depth of flavour. This whisky needs a touch of water to bring out the flavours hidden in the peat. Also ignore the first taste which feels harsh and acidic.
But by the second sip you suddenly notice the sweet sugars of the boiled sweets and the cinnamon on the finish that suddenly appears.
A well round 12 year old that carries what can only de described as charactor... A definitive smokey charactor.
Marcus,
Caol Ila is a very clean smokey Scotch. It is not as meaty as Laphroaig, which is also very good.
David,
Amazing speechless I’ve never try nothing like it
guest,
Peaty scotch with a long finish.
Ramesh,
Very warm and peaty! Drink it neat or maybe with a drop of water.
If you love your Lagavulin 16, you will love this too.
Kushal,
Loved this Scotch!! Finished half a bottle in no time.
guest,
A-
Susanna,
I liked a lot this Cask strength. It needs a drop of water and the taste improves. I detected cinnamon, but it was not too strong. A good purchase indeed.
Chris,
Nice scotch but much less body than a Lagavulin 16 or Laphroaig 10. Felt very thin and finish was a little too quickly gone for my taste.
Justin,
One of my favorite scotchs of all time. Smokey and smooth.
Simone,
Absolutely powerful.
Daniel,
Balanced peat and smake. I can see why it is used in a few on the Johnnie Walker blends.
guest,
Love
Chad,
Our least favorite of the 3 peaty scotches in the tasting box. Perhaps some seaweed smell and flavor. More of a love-it-or-hate-it type scotch.
Michael,
Nose has the familiar Islay smoke with underlying vanilla and a bit of heather and salt tang. Flavours are very bright and sweet up front, giving a bit of a delay before smoke gradually eases onto the palate. A peppery spice joins the smoke into the finish, along with tobacco and mild herbal notes. This is possibly the most refined Islay I've tried to this point- with its welcoming sweetness and gentle smoke character this might be an ideal 'starter' Islay Scotch.
Todd,
mellow and smokey
Thomas,
This is undoubtedly the marijuana of the Islay world. Its light peatiness acts as a seductress to its bolder, less well intentioned brothern. As an avid scotch drinker not big on peat, this delicios dram introduced me to a new world. Although I still lean on the Highlands and Speysides, I now proudly keep several Islays around. A must have for any scotch enthusiast!
Karolis,
Very nice, will go hunt some independent bottlings with higher abv
alexey,
Peaty and salty. Smooth and long finish. Very nice
Nate,
High amount of smoke with a little reflux. Very similar to Lagavulin but the warming sensation stays in your chest longer.
Bradley,
Delicious. Balanced smoke and peat with nice spice on the tongue
Troy,
Balances smoke and peat without being one note. A pleasant finish on a lighter dram than others in the region.
Patrick,
Smoke & honey
Keith,
My favorite scotch so far. Like a camp fire on an ocean cliff in your mouth. Smoky and salty nose and smooth smoooooth finish.
guest,
Great mix of smokiness and flavors
Eduardo,
Nice bright gold color. At nose smoky notes are first perceived but under that you can find some pepper and herbs. In the mouth a bit warm with medium long aftertaste
NICK,
Smoky, peaty aroma. Sweet and smoky with a touch of a bite. Pretty decent but whistlepig is still king. Mac $50/bottle.
guest,
Really pitted. Maybe too pitted.
Matt,
It was good... I was a little worried... This is only my second peat I have tried... No pun intended... My first peat left a bad taste in my mouth... This one agrees with my tastes a whole lot better.
Michael,
Its good - but the 12 year old expression is bested by other Caol Ila offerings.
Myke,
A nice Smokey islay that has more herbal and peppery notes. It’s Nita lay less peaty than the islands other offerings.
Patrick,
too much peat for me
Kevin,
Smooth, nice aftertaste
Christine,
Grassy, sweet notes in the aroma, alongside the smoke and peat. Not all that smooth - the bite of it is a little overwhelming and distracts from the flavor. If comparing to its Islay brethren, this reminds me more of an Ardbeg 10 than a Lagavulin 16. It's light and refreshing, but not very complex.
Andrej,
Good price performance! But overall the taste is not ballanced.
Jedediah,
Way to smoky for me. If you like a smoky drink though this one is for you.
Thaine,
Excellent. Smoky, yet refreshing. A new favorite.
Danny,
Love the superficial notes of peat and smoke. Was surprised I picked up on the cinnamon. Delicious.
Steve,
Strong peat taste
Gordon,
I found it a bit too harsh & extremely peaty. I had to add a drop of water to make it palatable. (I do not like mixing malt) I compareed it with an Arran peated, Machrie Moor. This I found was perfect.
Herbert,
great aroma
guest,
X
Harrison,
Light, bit peaty but not too bad
Daniel,
At first whif, floral notes but they discipate quick, releasing the smoke and peat. The same for the palate; first hits the floral with a medium strength, about 10 seconds later (rough guestimate) the smokey peat rolls in. I sense some caramel at the end which is a great combination to add with the smokey peat. At second thought, the reason why i gave this Caol such a high rating is because it is actually and nice change of combination to have the floral mixed with smokey peaty caramel. It helps you appreciate the peaty type scotch so much more.
Tristan,
Pale gold. Fruity nose with delicate smoke notes and a touch of petrol. The notes on the palate (smoke, wood, herbs, and spice) are soft and not really accentuated. I feel it does better with a couple drops of water or on ice. Not as great as I was hoping it to be, but still enjoyable.
simon,
What a lovely whiskey with plenty of character.
Mariano,
Very smoothy. Probably much more than any other I've tasted so far. Liked a lot though, perhaps it's spirits are absolutely complex.
Jonathan,
Did not enjoy at all. Not much else to say.
guest,
Good, just not a favourite. Bit bitey.
James,
A good dram sweetly smoked and peaty.
guest,
Heavy smoke, peated, Peppery
guest,
This is a more softer whisky untill the smokey touch comes. Then it changes to a more strong and smokey whisky. The aftertaste is quite short but slightly bitter. Nice whisky, very accessable.
Johann,
Really oily (too oily for my taste) and very smokey. It's probably the Sledgehammer of the #peaty Whiskys.
Polona,
Gentle straight peat - fresh hay, citrus and sweet. Slightly medicinal until well aired.
Balanced and quite complex with long, nice aftertaste
Chris,
Just the right amount of smoke.
Andrew,
Very peaty. Fairly sour with some spice. A lot of brine.
guest,
One of my favourites...
David,
Definite notes of sweet and peaty. I prefer more cinnamon but I am enjoying it.
guest,
Manque un peu de relief
guest,
It has a smoky, spicy taste. Not too peaty. Almost like a Glen Livet
Alex,
The peat flavor is extremely strong, basically overwhelming the other flavors, ruining the experience.
Will,
nice
Eric,
Caol Ila 12 Year Old is now one of my favorite Islays. Very smooth, great peat, and an amazing smokiness. To me, this is very subtle, yet complex enough to be interesting. Wonderful. I immediately purchased a bottle.
David,
An excellent smokey and peaty Islay. Definitely will buy again.
Mel,
Nose of vanilla and delicious peat. Light mouthfeel with medium finish. Very drinkable for beginners to Islay Scotch.
Stephen,
I wasn't impressed. There wasn't anything that really stood out. The oiliness was there, as well as the peat, but nothing to really stand out from the other scotches.
Eric,
Caol Ila 12 Year Old is one of my favorite single malts. I prefer smoky/peaty/spicy whiskys and this one has an added bonus of being a little stronger than usual.
Craig,
Wonderful salty smell with a peat rush. One of my favourite Islay malts
Ben,
If you want smokey and peaty- this is top shelf!
guest,
Spicy, and nice amount of smoke
guest,
Delicious, so much value for money. I love all of Islay and the first glass of CI 12 isn't different. Not as smoky and peaty as I remembering Ardbeg 10 and Laphroaig 10, it's in the middle of those and Lagavulin 16 and Bunna 12. I must say that Caol has more to it and to me it's a 'younger Lagavulin'. The balance makes this whisky superb and therefore for the relative cheap price a 9!
guest,
Not quite as smoky as Laphroaig, but similar in flavor without being quite as harsh on the front end.
guest,
Mm mm, so good!
Chris,
I thought the oil, peat and phenols were a bit overpowering in this whiskey.
David,
Joy
Giacomo,
PEATY
guest,
Was my birthday present...love it!!
Dumitru,
Smoky, peaty and smooth one of my favorites.
guest,
Отлично. Немного грубоват, но я прощаю. За дым, торф и остальные прелести....
Christopher,
Character. Best enjoyed on a cold winter evening.
Phillip,
Love this scotch. Nice middle of the road Islay. Great flavor and not overly peated.
guest,
Strong
guest,
I'm a huge fan of all things Caol Ila. The softest smoke on Islay. Beautiful whisky.
Pawan,
Smoky Peaty light
Michael,
What a great dram! Very balanced and smooth.
guest,
Соленая сладость, обжигает. Сухой вкус, дубовый, достаточно грубый
Maurizio,
My favorite standard. End of story. :)
Brendan,
Smoke sea brine peat and fruit. Pair with a lobster.
Back
